I have been buying this cologne for my husband for about 8 years, and it is one of the BEST, Elegant and sensual in the same time!! It brings the best out of what you're wearing and drew people towards you in a very settle and interesting way! I have bought 2 other different colognes for him, and every time he uses Black Walnut, I ask him which one you have on? It smells soo good! lol. However, every man's chemistry is different so like any other cologne it may be awesome on some but not all!